Categories
Animal Emotions Dealing with fear Problem Solving

Fireworks, Thunder, and Fear: The Complete Graded Guide to Canine Noise Phobia

… Is your dog afraid of fireworks? How about thunder?

Keep reading, this blog post contains everything you need to know.

… Is your dog *not* fearful of fireworks, thunder or other loud noise?

Keep reading anyway. That may change, and you should be prepared. What’s more, you can prevent it from ever becoming an issue.

This post is updated about twice a year, last on May 31st, 2026 – look for the “revised” signs in the post to find the latest changes.

It’s the combination of different techniques that produce the best effect (Crowell-Davis et al., 2003: 93%). Nobody’s tried using all the techniques suggested in this blog post, as far as I know.

Is the noise starting already? Jump straight to what to do now.

Categories
Animal Training Ethics How we learn Problem Solving Weathering scepticism

“Sheep-proofing” dogs in Norway

There was an article in a Norwegian dog magazine (an English translation is in the comments’ section below) this week, essentially claiming that by delivering an electric shock to a dog a single time as it runs towards a flock of sheep, you can stop it from ever chasing sheep again. Indeed, it gets a diploma to show that it’s “sheep-proofed”. There are no other ways of teaching this behaviour, the article claims, and also, it suggests that it’s a way to increase the overall quality of life of the shocked dogs.

The article implies that a single shock in a single location is all it takes to make dogs sheep-proof forever.

Needless to say, this article has stirred a lot of feelings within the Norwegian R+ community.

And for good reason.

Now, I don’t train dogs myself, but reading through it I found I have four areas of concern:

Categories
Animal Training Ethics How we learn Problem Solving Weathering scepticism

A critique of the “banana” shock collar study

Revised November 2026.

On this blog, I typically focus on animal emotion, learning and welfare, and on helping people transition away from coercive methods by giving them robust and compassionate alternatives.

But true progress in this field depends on good science. So when a peer-reviewed study publishes a cartoonish caricature of reward-based training and calls it science, it muddies the waters for everyone trying to do better by their animals.

I’m referring to the Comparison of the Efficacy and Welfare of Different Training Methods in Stopping Chasing Behavior in Dogs (2024, Johnson & Wynne).

This study has since its publication been cited in some circles as proof that positive reinforcement utterly fails in high-drive predatory contexts. Since it proves nothing of the sort, I feel a lengthy, occasionally nerdy and also somewhat rambling blog post pointing out the most flagrant problems is in order.

In short, the authors found that teaching dogs to refrain from chasing a fast-moving lure was effective in a novel environment in 2/3 of cases when shock-collars had been used during training, however attempting to train the behaviour in a slightly shorter time frame using “food rewards” (50 minutes as opposed to 60 for the shocked dogs) was essentially useless. They also saw no signs of distress or reduced welfare in the shocked dogs, except that all of them yelped in pain at some point.

I’m paraphrasing here, obviously.

Categories
Applied Ethology How we learn Problem Solving Weathering scepticism

The pros and cons of labelling animal behaviour.

Many animal behaviour consultants abhor labels.

They consider them not just pointless, but disastrous, and many of them wouldn’t be caught dead using labels.  

You might think I’m exaggerating for dramatic effect, and yes, I do have a penchant for hyperbole so it is entirely possible… but sometimes I do wonder. 

As an ethologist, I had merrily been using labels for decades without even realizing that they could be problematic. It was not until I started hanging out with behaviour analysts that it was pointed out to me.

I had two main reactions to that insight:

  • Wow, it’s really useful to realize that labels can be very detrimental!
  • Wow, some people really don’t seem to realize how useful labels can be!

When are labels useful? Well, as is the case with literally everything related to animals and their behaviour, it depends on the context.

Labels are sometimes useful, sometimes irrelevant, and sometimes harmful.

I can think of three useful types of label, and one label type that is harmful. And yet, the harmful labels are getting all the attention!

Categories
Problem Solving

Using antecedent strategies to resolve challenging behaviour

Updated November 2022.

During the pandemic, I was crazy busy preparing a novel course, called Resolving Challenging Behaviour, all about, you guessed it, resolving challenging behaviour in animals.

I’ve had a bunch of brave and enthusiastic pilot students help me develop the course, and one course chapter that they found specifically useful was the one on Antecedent Strategies.

So I thought I’d share it.

But, before I do that, I need to give you some back story.

Behaviour occurs in context

Unwanted behaviour doesn’t appear out of the blue – it occurs in specific contexts.

Perhaps a specific location, or in the presence of specific animals, people or other stimuli.

And in this context, the animal has an emotional reaction. And, because of that emotional reaction, he performs a behaviour.

The behaviour (red) occurs in a specific emotional context (orange) when the animal is in a specific mood (yellow). This model was heavily inspired by MHERA, formerly EMRA*.
Categories
Animal Emotions Interview Problem Solving

Separation anxiety – an interview with Eva Bertilsson

Separation anxiety, or to be more precise, separation-related problem behaviour (not necessarily caused by anxiety), is common in dogs.

About 50% of family dogs will show problem behaviour, related to separations, at some point in their lives.
  • What do we know about this phenomenon? Which dogs show it, and when?
  • What can we do to prevent, reduce or eliminate it?